IX7C3570.jpg

RADB Appeal Results - 2010

Hearing Date Name Suspension Rule No. Chairman Panel Result
29 March 2010 Daryl Douglas 10 days 163 (1)(a) Brian Collis QC Rod Osborne Appeal against conviction dismissed. Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 5 days.
12 April 2010 Philip Duffy $400 Fine 156(2) Brian Collis QC John Denahy Appeal dismissed. 
30 April 2010 Ellen Tormey 2 weeks 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC John Dix Appeal against conviction dismissed. Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 1 week.
30 April 2010 Brian Shelley 2 weeks 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC John Dix Appeal against conviction dismissed. Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 1 week.
19 May 2010 Rhys Nicholson 4 weeks 149(1) Brian Collis QC Brian Pearce/Phillip Byrne Appeal dismissed.
03 June 2010 Shane Graham 2 weeks & $500 fine 163(1)(a) Tony Burns Rod Osborne Appeal was withdrawn 28 May 2010.  Ordered to pay costs of $196.
03 June 2010 Scott Dyer $1,000 fine 163(1)(a) Tony Burns Rod Osborne Appeal dismissed.
17 June 2010 Alexander Douglas 8 weeks 149(1) Brian Collis QC Kevin Carson Appeal against conviction dismissed. Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 6 weeks.
17 June 2010 Nathan Jack 2 weeks 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC Kevin Carson Appeal against conviction dismissed. Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 10 days.
02 July 2010 Daryl Douglas 2 weeks 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC John Denahy Appeal upheld.
02 July 2010 Gerrard Surkitt 5 weeks 149(1) Brian Collis QC John Denahy Appeal against conviction dismissed. Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 4 weeks.
20 July 2010 Andrew Vozlic 6 weeks 149(1) Tony Burns John Dix Appeal upheld.
20 July 2010 Craig Northcott 8 weeks 162(1)(www) Tony Burns John Dix Appeal against conviction dismissed. Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 4 weeks.
  Ian Dornauf 6 weeks 149(2) and 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC   Appeal was denied due to late submission.
02 August 2010 Ian Dornauf $250 fine 44(1) Brian Collis QC   Appeal was withdrawn prior to hearing date.
02 August 2010 Royce Gregory-Jack 6 weeks 149(1) Brian Collis QC Phillip Byrne Appeal dismissed.
02 August 2010 Ellen Tormey 3 weeks 149(2) Brian Collis QC Phillip Byrne Appeal upheld.
04 August 2010 Peter Salathiel 2 weeks 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC Brian Pearce Appeal against conviction dismissed. Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 12 days.
17 August 2010 Craig Demmler 10 days 167(2) Brian Collis QC Kevin Carson Appeal against conviction dismissed.  Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 10 days.
23 August 2010 Rodney Petroff 2 weeks 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC Phillip Byrne Appeal dismissed.
30 August 2010 Brian Sylvia 2 weeks 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC John Denahy Appeal dismissed.
30 August 2010 Brian Sylvia $500 fine 231(2) Brian Collis QC John Denahy Appeal against conviction dismssed.  Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to $250 fine.
30 August 2010 Rita Burnett $500 fine 273(1) Tony Burns Rod Osborne Appeal against conviction dismssed.  Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to $300 fine.
30 August 2010 Derrick Krafft 5 weeks 149(1) Tony Burns Rod Osborne Hearing adjourned to 21 September 2010
21 September 2010 Derrick Krafft 5 weeks 149(1) Tony Burns Rod Osborne Appeal against conviction dismissed.  Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 4 weeks.
18 October 2010 Phillip Walters 2 weeks 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC Rod Osborne Appeal against conviction and penalty dismissed.
20 October 2010 Phillip Walters Suspended until HRV RAD Board hearing in Jan/Feb 2011 183(d) Brian Collis QC Tony Burns Appeal against suspension of trainer's licence dismissed.  Suspended until the outcome of HRV RAD Board hearing in Jan/Feb 2011.

Appeal against suspension of driver's licence varied. Only permitted to drive in races and perform stablehand duties at racecourse only.  Not permitted to assist in the training of any horse. Conditions remain in place until the completion of HRV RAD Board hearing in Jan/Feb 2011.
25 November 2010 Greg Sugars 2 weeks 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC Phillip Byrne Appeal against conviction dismissed.  Appeal against penalty upheld and varied to 10 days.
25 November 2010 Andrew Clarke $1,500 fine 273(7) Brian Collis QC Phillip Byrne Appeal against severity of penalty upheld and varied to $1,000 fine.
01 December 2010 Emmett Brosnan 4 weeks 163(1)(c) Brian Collis QC Noel Perry, Brian Pearce Appeal dismissed.
23 December 2010 John Justice 3 weeks 163(1)(a) Brian Collis QC John Denahy Appeal dismissed.
23 December 2010 Frank Scicluna Suspended until HRV RAD Board hearing 23/12/10 183(d) Brian Collis QC John Denahy Breach of Rule 187(3) - $500 fine
Breach of Rule 248 - $500 fine
Charge relating to breach of sectional time requirements was withdrawn by Stewards